Even though the concert runs a little over an hour, Collins goes through so many songs that you truly feel like it made for a longer event. Her voice by now has become less smooth, and much more powerful, she sings every note as if each of them contained a universe of emotion. Her rendition of “Finishing the Hat” is positively goosebump-inducing, and one can’t help but be thankful she didn’t go the obvious route by pairing all songs by the musical they came from. She does seem to favor Sunday in the Park With George, from which she also sings “Sunday” and “Children & Art”, but really who can blame her for loving that show?
What’s truly exciting is when she marries songs that seem to come from extreme opposites, and finds the connection between them, such as when she does “Guns” from Assassins, followed by “There Won’t Be Trumpets” from Anyone Can Whistle, the former’s humor making way to the bittersweet nature of the latter. Collins explains that Sondheim has “gone out on a limb and created beauty”, but so has she with her unique renditions of his work, and for that reason A Love Letter to Stephen Sondheim is essential.
DVD extras include an interview with Collins in which she details how she first became aware of Sondheim (she didn’t know who he was before someone suggested she recorded “Send in the Clowns”), and rehearsal footage from the concert.
Judy Collins' A Love Letter to Stephen Sondheim will be available on the MVD Shop or on Amazon on 02/24.