Reading the title, one would imagine “The Case Against 8” as an intense John Grisham thriller. In actuality, filmmakers Ben Cotner & Ryan White deliver a heartwarming, inside look at the case against California’s gay marriage ban, Prop 8. At heart, the film scores with a universal story of love and equality. The insightful documentary opens with an intense briefing with defending attorney Ted Olson, followed by images of Barack Obama winning the presidential election, a moment that comes full circle later. Olson plays an interesting role in this case given that in the past he served as adviser for both Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush. Taking this case and working with former rival David Boies makes some feel he’s a traitor to the Republican party.
Two gay California couples, Sandy & Kris and Paul & Jeff, are then introduced as the center of the historical case. The film follows their lives throughout their five year legal battle. The film seems to slightly focus into the lives of Sandy & Kris more because their story adds an extra layer by showcasing a blended family. One of the film's best scenes has Paul & Jeff’s families celebrating the holidays. Both sides are very supportive of their relationship and encourage them to go through with the trial. The trial itself is a roller coaster and while we know the outcome, the film does a great job of keeping you invested.
While the case is the center, the most effective moments in the film occur outside the courtroom. Seeing the couples in their personal moments, like the holiday scene, are what touch you. These moments show that these couples are just like anyone else. You may know the case ends happily, but seeing the journey to get there adds emotional impact. After winning the case, we get to see Barack Obama call in to applaud both couples, coming full circle from beginning. The film ends with Attorney General Kamala Harris and LA Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa officiating the marriages. “The Case Against 8” is overall a fantastic documentary and a great love story. It's an insightful watch and a must see.
The film opens in select theaters on June 6 followed by an HBO premiere on June 23.
